What are reproducible builds?

Reproducible builds are a set of software development practices that create a verifiable path from human readable source code to the binary code used by computers.

Most aspects of software verification are done on source code, as that is what humans can reasonably understand. But most of the time, computers require software to be first built into a long string of numbers to be used. With reproducible builds, multiple parties can redo this process independently and ensure they all get exactly the same result. We can thus gain confidence that a distributed binary code is indeed coming from a given source code.

(Quoted from https://reproducible-builds.org)

Tails ISO images should be reproducible: everybody who builds the ISO should be able to obtain the exact same resulting ISO image from a given Git tag.

Why is it important?

Reproducibility increases confidence in the value of our continuous quality assurance processes as well as the trust that users, and anyone interested can put into our released build products (such as ISO images) and our development and release process.

Reproducible builds help detect bugs and ensure that there is no bit flip that makes us waste precious hours during a release process.

Most important, a reproducible build allows for independent verification that a build product matches what the source intended to produce. This helps to better resist attacks against build machines and developers, improves users' security, and allows developers to sleep better at night (as the incentive for an attacker to compromise developers' systems, or to compromise developers themselves, is lowered). In turn, this avoids the need to trust people (or software) who build the ISO we release, which in turn allows more people to get involved in release management work.

Release managers do not have to upload the ISO image anymore when they do a release: they can instead build it both on our infrastructure (Jenkins) and locally and compare the outputs: if they match, one can publish the ISO built by Jenkins. Uploading an ISO can take many hours with some commonly found means of accessing the Internet, so removing the need to go through this step decreases our time to remediation for fixing security issues, and makes it easier for developers with poor access to the Internet to take care of a release.

Build and compare a Tails ISO image

Build a Tails ISO image

See the build instructions.

How do I verify the ISO I have built against the official one?

You can verify that the ISO image you have built is identical to the official one we published either with OpenPGP or with a checksum.

Verify with OpenPGP

When you reproducibly build our ISO you should obtain a file that is exactly the same as the official Tails ISO image, thus, our signature should be able to verify your ISO for you.

Download and verify our OpenPGP signature against your own ISO image.

Verify with a checksum

To verify that the ISO image you have built is identical as the official one:

  1. Compute the checksum of your ISO image by executing the following command on it:

     sha256sum yourimage.iso
  2. Compare the SHA-256 checksum of your ISO image with the one found in the official ISO description file.

Build and compare a Tails upgrade (IUK)

Build a Tails IUK

See Build the Incremental Upgrade Kits section in our Release process documentation.

Verify IUKs

You can get the SHA-256 of any IUK by setting the SOURCE and TARGET variables appropriately, for example:

# For Tails_amd64_3.0_to_3.1.iuk

and then run:

if gpg --verify ${UDF}.pgp ${UDF}; then
  python3 <<EOF
import yaml
with open('${UDF}') as f:
  data = yaml.load(f)
upgrade = next(x for x in data['upgrades']
               if x['version'] == '${TARGET}')
incremental = next(x for x in upgrade['upgrade-paths']
                   if x['type'] == 'incremental')
iuk = next(x for x in incremental['target-files']
           if x['url'].endswith('Tails_amd64_${SOURCE}_to_${TARGET}.iuk'))
print('SHA-256:', iuk['sha256'])
  echo 'OpenPGP verification of the UDF failed. Are you sure you have ' \
       'Tails signing key imported into you keyring?' >&2

Related information

More detailed information can be found on our blueprint about Reproducible Builds.