Future work

Using NetwokManager for AvoidConnectionProbs?

Instead of our current hack, we'd ideally want to hook into NetworkManager's error handling, which certainly would be more robust, and hopefully would provide more information about the error, but this currently seems unsupported.

An experiment has showed that when connecting to a password-protected (WPA-PSK) wireless network with MAC address white-listing, spoofed (and hence blocked) MAC addresses resulted in an endless cycle of NM asking for passphrase. When cancelled, NM displays a "Disconnected" notification, and during this time no NM dispatcher events were emitted.

Some bugs of interest that may bring some hope:

Vendor bit randomisation with macchiato

These are the current relevant OUI counts from macchiato's git:

5 oui/bluetooth_laptop.sh 2 oui/bluetooth_misc.sh 12 oui/bluetooth_mobile.sh 1 oui/bluetooth_pmp.sh 2 oui/wired_console.sh 3 oui/wired_desktop_dedicated.sh 11 oui/wired_desktop_onboard.sh 8 oui/wired_infrastructure.sh 17 oui/wired_laptop.sh 6 oui/wired_misc.sh 4 oui/wired_printer.sh 2 oui/wireless_camera.sh 1 oui/wireless_console.sh 4 oui/wireless_desktop_dedicated.sh 2 oui/wireless_desktop_onboard.sh 4 oui/wireless_handheld.sh 6 oui/wireless_infrastructure.sh 1 oui/wireless_laptop_dedicated.sh 21 oui/wireless_laptop.sh 17 oui/wireless_mobile.sh 7 oui/wireless_pmp.sh 4 oui/wireless_printer.sh 8 oui/wireless_usb.sh

In particular there's ~20 each in wireless_laptop and wired_laptop, which is what we should care about most (desktops rarely need MAC spoofing). However, after investigating the sources for some OUI:s (via git history), some OUI:s are (according to the submitter) only common in certain geographical areas. This makes the lists too small and unreliable at the moment.

There are others attempts at collecting MAC addresses for various kinds of hardware:

Questions, remaining issues, and other random stuff

MAC spoof failure warning and failsafe

If MAC spoofing fails for some interface we'd like to prevent it from exposing the real MAC address, and warn the user about this via a notification.

In the current implementation there's no failsafe that verifies that the selected MAC spoofing setting has been enforced before connecting. This would be easy if there was something like pre-up NM dispatcher hooks but just like in the section about "Connection failure detection", there's none yet.

An alternative would be to do this in config/chroot local-includes/usr/local/sbin/tails-spoof-mac, which is run by the udev hook. In the end of the script we could try to verify that the spoofing indeed happened for the NIC in question, and if it didn't we could go into full-out panic mode:

  1. Down the interface
  2. Try to unload the module used by the NIC. While one easily can find the module used by a $NIC via readlink "/sys/class/net/${NIC}/device/driver/module", we'd also have to resolve reverse dependencies. For instance, for current Intel wireless chipsets, the iwlwifi module is loaded, but with current Linux kernels another module called iwldvm is loaded, and it uses iwlwifi, so a morprobe -r iwlwifi will fail. Sadly modprobe doesn't have a --recursive-remove or --show-reverse-depends so we'd have to e.g. parse "Used by" field of lsmod or similar, and we'd have to do it recursively to be rigorous.
  3. Perhaps prevent NetworkManager from starting if the previous step failed?
  4. Show a scary error message to the user

It would obviously require to drop set -e, because errors are indeed what could cause this to happen.

Detecting MAC-spoof related connection errors for wired NICs

While Wi-Fi connection are covered, this gets trickier for wired connections. The problem is that there's no strong concept of being "associated" to a wired network (at least a "standard" one, perhaps there is with 802.1x security...). It'll probably be hard to identify blocking without confusing it with other types of wired connection failures (i.e. false positives). How does wired MAC address blocking usually work? On which level? DHCP? Lower layer?

Old stuff from blueprint

Improving macchanger

Some of our goals would be easier to achieve by patching macchanger itself. Since it's been unmaintained upstream for a while, we've been discussing and working with someone who has taken its maintenance over and has already started patching it to better suit our needs:

  • Redmine project
  • Git repository: git://labs.riseup.net/backupninja.git
  • Debian packages: the maintainer of the macchanger package in Debian has already integrated some of these patches (uploaded to sid: 1.5.0-8) and is likely to go on this way. Tails has been using this improved version for a while.

Inspiration sources

Haven

Haven does not automatically start network-manager at boot time. It provides shortcuts in the application menu to run macchanger-gtk and start the network if desired.

Liberte Linux

Liberte Linux randomises wireless MAC addresses at boot time and allows changing wired interfaces' MAC addresses after boot, see their src/usr/local/sbin/mac-randomize that uses ifconfig IFACE hw ether rather than macchanger.

Documentation

Investigate and possibly document the kind of information that could still be seen on the LAN about the system. Such as the manufacturer (ex: Sony), model number, BIOS and version, etc.?